About American Advantage
Your Pewaukee Insurance Agency

We offer a consultative approach to get to know you and construct an insurance program that makes sense. We’ll work together with you and the insurance companies we represent to structure an insurance program with coverage, risk management and ancillary services that benefit you.

We offer free second opinions on your insurance program to identify areas that may need improvement. If we find holes in your protection, we’ll let you know how they can be plugged.

We’re an independent insurance agency that represents more than one insurance company. That gives our customers coverage and pricing options. Contact us for a no obligation, free second opinion.

Insurance can be confusing. Contact us for a plain language explanation of your personal and business exposures and how to cover them.

“Lisa has been very helpful in providing guidance for both my business and personal insurance. Especially in explaining alternatives and reasons for her recommendations. I recommend her without reservation.”

our team

pewaukee office

sussex office

  • After years of fragmentation, my wife and I realize our coverage needed to be pulled together with a single carrier. Lisa and the people of American Advantage made this so easy. The quotes and information provided were very clear, our questions were answered with a high level of industry knowledge and scheduling a meeting with Lisa could not have been easier. She worked around our busy schedules and guided us through the entire process. We will definitely refer questioning friends to American Advantage.

    Joel & Alecia E.
  • I’ve worked with several insurance professionals in my 33 year career in the financial service industry and Lisa Triscari is a top performer in the industry. She’s a knowledgeable professional who goes above and beyond in providing high quality service and value to her clients. I am proud to refer Lisa to anyone I know!

    Dan J.
  • I have had American Advantage IFS handling my business and personal insurance for many years. Everyone there is a joy to work with and I have the utmost confidence in everything they do for me. It is great knowing that my best interests and well being are the center of every insurance decision that is made. There is no price tag that can put on my piece of mind because of what they do for me.

    Kathy G.
  • “Lisa has handled our insurance for over 15 years. When she left another insurance agency we had been working with we followed her to American Advantage. She has always been responsive to our individual needs and her professionalism means prompt and courteous responses. We are always confident that her coverage recommendations and advice are what is best for us. And if Lisa is unavailable for some reason, the other staff always handle my immediate needs as they are attentive to even my simplest concerns and knowledgeable about the world of insurance. I highly recommend American Advantage to our family or friends for great service and good sound insurance advice.”

    Linda M.
  • “I have been working with these folks for 20 years now and have seen nothing but high integrity and always putting the client first. I am very particular who I refer my clients to and American Advantage – IFS are the only ones I trust. I know they will work in the best interest of my clients.”

    Bart Harter Owner of Strategic Financial
  • “Mike’s knowledgeable and experienced as an insurance agent is where his clients refer him above all others. His abilities to shop different companies to get the best fit for the best price keeps him a step above the rest.”

    Debora Smith
  • “Mike has always shown a compassion and understanding of his client’s needs. By his nature he goes the extra step to ensure details are properly handled. He truly does become a trusted advisor.”

    Jory Pradjinski Account Executive, Triad Creative Group, Inc
  • “Lisa has been very helpful in providing guidance for both my business and personal insurance. Especially in explaining alternatives and reasons for her recommendations. I recommend her without reservation.”

    KIrby Watson

Insurance Companies We Represent

Want to learn more? Check out our blog for helpful tips!

Start typing and press Enter to search